A History of Paper
by Oliver Emanuel and Gareth Williams
starring Alan Cumming
Shirley Henderson
A Pitlochry Festival Theatre and Dundee Rep production
review written by Louise Cannon

A History of Paper is absorbing, poignant and one of the most tender well-observed love stories to be told on a stage. It’s a flawless performance!
The minimalist staging suits the musical about a man and a woman falling in love and works better for this play than one that is large sets and glitz. One piano and two actors on stage, some undramatic, yet beautiful lighting and few props.
As Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson sing, their voices complement each other extremely well.
Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson make you love and deeply invest in the characters they play.
The year is 1999. There’s a box with a van (artistically emphasised in the play). Inside the box with a van are letters, receipts and a Pizza Express menu. Junk to others, but treasures and memories to behold…
Time is re-wound to the reminiscing of simpler times of of the 90’s when letter writing was a thing. Observe the tenses used in the conversations and narratives.
The construction sparks questions fairly early on, that do get answered by the end.
The chemistry between Alan Cumming and Shirley Henderson is palpable.

Radiohead playing too loudly, causing the two neighbours to meet, is the start of the unfolding of a love story. From there we see dating at Pizza Express and nuanced body-language as well as the flamboyancy of joy of that first flush of love. There is also the sweetness of the Japanese art-form of oragami and chat that is sometimes nuanced, sometimes coming together and at other times, a bit awkward and sitting at juxtapositions. It’s all rather naturally performed.

A magical romantic new year’s eve on the beach, where a beautiful light show of lanterns emerges.
Woven cleverly into this love story are also the conversations of the time, such as climate change. People in the 90’s of many ages were practically prophesying what was going to happen and now as we see, getting it right. Amusingly and thankfully some things that didn’t turn out to be true like”Millennium Bug,” before returning a romantic time that oozes enough love to capture anyone’s heart.
The noughties arrive and there is an almighty twist that is so poignantly and so tenderly played out as everything changes but still ensures beauty and hope isn’t forgotten about in the most surprising of ways.
The play poignantly poses a question about what scraps/letters etc would you keep?
By the end there was a well-deserved standing ovation.
You can catch A History of Paper at Pitlochry Festival Theatre from 9 August to 12 September 2026, before transferring to Dundee Rep Theatre from 16–19 September.
Check out the link here: https://www.pitlochryfestivaltheatre.com/whats-on/a-history-of-paper/






















